Profile Picture

Why I am beginning to hate 3dxchange

Posted By gogstudios 9 Years Ago
You don't have permission to rate!
Author
Message
gogstudios
gogstudios
Posted 9 Years Ago
View Quick Profile
Distinguished Member

Distinguished Member (2.2K reputation)Distinguished Member (2.2K reputation)Distinguished Member (2.2K reputation)Distinguished Member (2.2K reputation)Distinguished Member (2.2K reputation)Distinguished Member (2.2K reputation)Distinguished Member (2.2K reputation)Distinguished Member (2.2K reputation)Distinguished Member (2.2K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Last Active: 6 Years Ago
Posts: 51, Visits: 326
Alright. It's time to get it out there. I purchased iClone and the whole bundle for 600$ looking at the promotions and the trailers. 3DXchange was advertised as this big bridge between iClone and any 3D program out there. I thought I could import and export any model in and out of 3DXchange to ANY 3D program. I bought iClone with the intention of making quick characters for my game, be it the main character or an NPC. Let's be clear, my intention was never to find the perfect model right out of character creator or get the perfect set of morph shapes handed to me by iClone. My goal was simply to have fully customizable characters generated by the character creator which I could then use 3DXchange to export, make modifications like change poly count, decimate for NPC characters etc.

Now comes the part where my hopes have been shattered and my money has been burnt. So, being an indie developer myself and unable to afford a Maya license which costs a whopping 4.500$, I have been using BLENDER for quite some time now learning sculpting, retopology and all the intermediate stuff. Here is the biggest problem that I faced. I exported a basic character that looks like this from CC through iClone to 3dXchange:


Imported this in blender with different 3dXchange export configs and different blender import configs(I tried them all, brute forcing every single combination). The best result I got was this:
https://forum.reallusion.com/uploads/images/832f32ce-0590-403b-9e1f-35ef.png
Observe the scene objects and how they do not have a parent.

Looks at the hands and the breast area. Also, notice the boots.
Now, one theory was that all of this looked bad just in blender. So, I exported this imported fbx from blender, opened the exported fbx in 3dXchange to get this weird result:

I tried every export configuration in blender for fbx and all of them resulted in the same mess.
So, now tell me if this software should even be sold at any price? The sole purpose of 3dxchange is maintaining compatibility with other 3D programs and there aren't many of them on the market, just about 6-7 programmes. So, why does this half broken crap of a software exist? I request the reallusion team to take a hard look at their bundle and think if they are really doing their best.
P.S. If anyone has a workaround for the 3dXchange to blender pipeline, do post it as an answer.

SkyRoads clone for Android: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.gog.skyroads
Target Number - A math puzzle game: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.tomag.targetNumber


Threaded View

Threaded View
Forum Post Why I am beginning to hate 3dxchange By gogstudios ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post From the image of the FBX import, it looks like your using an older... By Rampa ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post Hi Rampa. I am using the latest version of blender as its installed... By gogstudios ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post I don't know why I am replying here. Doesn't look like reallusion team... By gogstudios ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]gogstudios (9/4/2016)[/b][hr]I don't know why I am replying... By animagic ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]gogstudios (9/4/2016)[/b][hr]I don't know why I am replying... By Peter (RL) ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote]Conclusion: 3dx is more crappy than I imagined[/quote]... By vidi ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post @vidi Just to be clear, I know that CC functionality cannot be used... By gogstudios ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]gogstudios (9/4/2016)[/b][hr]@animagic Fair enough. I will... By justaviking ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post Hi justaviking. I will do that tomorrow. I think I am close getting it... By gogstudios ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote]Just to be clear, I know that CC functionality cannot be used... By vidi ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post Hi Vidi. The vertex order CANNOT be changed only in these cases 1. If... By gogstudios ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post To be compatible with the existing CC morphs, the face count and... By Rampa ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post Hi Rampa. What I love about CC is that it creates pretty good quality... By gogstudios ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote]Hi Vidi. The vertex order CANNOT be changed only in these... By vidi ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post Hi Vidi. [quote] 1.All I want is to add few polys to the face... By gogstudios ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post However In context, you write it contradictory for me. Why... By vidi ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post I never mentioned that I wanted to import into CC. I wanted to import... By gogstudios ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post Finally! I got this thing to work! *Patting my own back* First of... By gogstudios ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post Wow--this forum is a gold mine for iClone and 3D Exchange problems.... By Blazoneer ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]Blazoneer (11/18/2016)[/b][hr]Wow--this forum is a gold mine... By animagic ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post @HeadClot: When I mentioned philosophical differences that is what I... By animagic ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post RL works pretty closely with Autodesk, I believe. You can be assured... By Rampa ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post It should be noted Blender is not wholly incompatible with iClone,... By eternityblue ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post I'm wondering if anyone has had better luck exporting from Blender to... By eternityblue ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post Blender FBX export of boned skinned models works quite well. Myself,... By Rampa ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]rampa (11/24/2016)[/b][hr]Blender FBX export of boned... By urbanlamb ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post There are people who make money with iClone. (Now wait and see. I... By animagic ( 9 Years Ago )



Reading This Topic