Profile Picture

[MajorIssue] Ambient Occlusion Should NOT Impact Diffuse Lighting

Posted By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS 9 Years Ago
You don't have permission to rate!

[MajorIssue] Ambient Occlusion Should NOT Impact Diffuse Lighting

Author
Message
GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS
GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS
Posted 9 Years Ago
View Quick Profile
Distinguished Member

Distinguished Member (9.2K reputation)Distinguished Member (9.2K reputation)Distinguished Member (9.2K reputation)Distinguished Member (9.2K reputation)Distinguished Member (9.2K reputation)Distinguished Member (9.2K reputation)Distinguished Member (9.2K reputation)Distinguished Member (9.2K reputation)Distinguished Member (9.2K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Last Active: 5 Years Ago
Posts: 1.2K, Visits: 7.2K
Hi,

"Ambient Occlusion", as its name implies, is a technique invented to gather the occlusion of ambient lighting (and nothing else).

An ambient occlusion map should then only affect ambient lighting, like 'Ambient' and 'IBL', but certainly not the diffuse lighting produced by Lights.

Here is an illustration, a character with Skin_Head channel without AO (well with the map but with strength at 0):
https://forum.reallusion.com/uploads/images/7417e9ad-0f5a-4966-8325-88c9.jpg 

And now with the Ambient Occlusion map and strength 100, again on the Skin_Head channel:
https://forum.reallusion.com/uploads/images/1d6c6bff-db21-4a9f-9ac0-3555.jpg

The result is completely black !?

This should not be, only the Ambient and IBL lighting should be affected by the black AO map, we should still see the Key and Rim lights diffuse lighting on the head.

--
guy rabiller | GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS
"N.O.E." (Nations Of Earth) Sci-Fi TV Show, Showrunner.


Threaded View

Threaded View
Forum Post [MajorIssue] Ambient Occlusion Should NOT Impact Diffuse Lighting By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post This strikes me as similar to using the reflection channel. It's not... By Rampa ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post It is a question of how the data is used rather of where the data... By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post It is pretty much like the Blend channel, actually. It is additional... By Rampa ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post I don't know how other applications do it, but I like the logic in... By justaviking ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]rampa (1/5/2017)[/b][hr]It is pretty much like the Blend... By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post @justaviking Exactly! ^^ By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post Sounds like a good issue for FeedBack Tracker. If you know what is... By justaviking ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post I think this requires some thought, because I never use IC6 style... By animagic ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post @animagic You are right we cannot refer to IC7 at this point, but... By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post the actual iclone piece has always had an extra AO feature in the... By urbanlamb ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]urbanlamb (1/5/2017)[/b][hr]the actual iclone piece has... By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]grabiller (1/5/2017)[/b][hr][quote][b]urbanlamb... By urbanlamb ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post @urbanlamb When arguing the artistic aspects of an image, an... By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post ....well maybe they will fix it then but then this means they need to... By urbanlamb ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post For my own education, I thought I would look into common definitions,... By animagic ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]animagic (1/6/2017)[/b][hr]For my own education, I thought I... By urbanlamb ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post I find Guy's argument (the good type of argument, as in debate)... By justaviking ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]justaviking (1/6/2017)[/b][hr]../..I feel real good about... By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]grabiller (1/6/2017)[/b][hr][quote][b]justaviking... By justaviking ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post ....just remember its not done yet so maybe i am not understanding his... By urbanlamb ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]animagic (1/6/2017)[/b][hr]For my own education, I thought I... By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post I was actually surprised that the ambient AO settings in the character... By Rampa ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]rampa (1/6/2017)[/b][hr]I was actually surprised that the... By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]grabiller (1/6/2017)[/b][hr][quote][b]rampa... By Rampa ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post @urbanlamb iClone7 or not, CC2 must correctly show surfacing results,... By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]grabiller (1/6/2017)[/b][hr]@urbanlamb iClone7 or not, CC2... By urbanlamb ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post This is a quote from the Allegrothmic PBR Guide vol. 2, page 18 on... By wires ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post @urbanlamb [quote]So I would not report it as a bug in this case... By wires ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post well then he should just report it as a bug because clearly its not... By urbanlamb ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]wires (1/6/2017)[/b][hr]@urbanlamb [quote]So I would not... By animagic ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post I think you guys are overcomplicating this (I believe in the KISS... By urbanlamb ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]urbanlamb (1/6/2017)[/b][hr]../..As for the actual result... By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post I said the lighting is not broken its reflecting what the maps (or... By urbanlamb ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]urbanlamb (1/6/2017)[/b][hr]../..I am using the CC2 white... By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post FYI... I got home from work early... I'll write up the Ambient... By justaviking ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]grabiller (1/6/2017)[/b][hr][quote][b]urbanlamb... By urbanlamb ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post Issue #1997:... By justaviking ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post LOL what's this? looks like its working on her dress. She is an... By urbanlamb ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]justaviking (1/6/2017)[/b][hr]Issue #1995:... By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post @urbanlamb - Your recent pictures support the position that CC2's... By justaviking ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post Its possible I guess I am not seeing it though. /shrug I just... By urbanlamb ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]urbanlamb (1/6/2017)[/b][hr]Its possible I guess I am not... By justaviking ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]grabiller (1/6/2017)[/b][hr]You forgot 3 things you will... By justaviking ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]urbanlamb (1/6/2017)[/b][hr][quote][b]grabiller... By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post here i just did something quickly this is done in 3dcoat and... By urbanlamb ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]urbanlamb (1/6/2017)[/b][hr]here i just did something... By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post The scene is lit with 1 light so yes there is light (its the default... By urbanlamb ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post @wires Ah..there is a need for some clarification here, because... By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post @urbanlamb I have 3dCoat myself and the "default" render setup is 1... By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]justaviking (1/6/2017)[/b][hr] Sometimes it would be so... By urbanlamb ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post oh well here is another one from the paint port which I think is... By urbanlamb ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post @justaviking No worries, that's perfectly ok. What matters ultimately... By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post Not that it seems to matter at this point, but the PBR characters... By animagic ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post [quote][b]animagic (1/7/2017)[/b][hr]Not that it seems to matter at... By urbanlamb ( 9 Years Ago )
Forum Post @urbanlamb You are right. There is not much to discuss when one report... By GOETZIWOOD STUDIOS ( 9 Years Ago )



Reading This Topic